Preview Mode Links will not work in preview mode

Barbell Logic


Jun 3, 2019

It's the million dollar question, right? When is strong... strong enough? For those who have been in the game for a while, it's not really a question at all. There is no strong enough, at least not for 99% of us. Life and other priorities get in the way of training enough that most of us never achieve a level of strength which is "strong enough." Those little, sometimes large, life deloads put us back into strength gaining mode as we fight to recover what was lost. Thus, from a practical standpoint, there's no point questioning whether one is strong enough.

 

But there's a philosophical argument against the notion of being strong enough, too. The acquisition of strength -- that is, training for it -- depends on goals: small goals, like adding 5lbs each workout, to larger and more long-term goals, like setting a new 1RM in each lift. These goals allow us to organize training systematically so that we can achieve them; they make training logical, systematic, and progressive. Without a distinct goal, training often becomes random, erratic, and unfocused. The notion of training to maintain strength, though seemingly logical on the surface, is not a concrete goal. How does one train to maintain, exactly?

 

We know from the SRA model that a stress must occur to continue driving adaptation. Without stress, there is no adaptation. More importantly, without stress there is regression, a loss of adaptation. So lifting with the intention of maintenance -- essentially lifting to preserve homeostasis -- is a sketchy proposition. On a practical level, if you try to continue squatting, say, 315 for 3x5 once a week, you'll likely notice that after a couple weeks it becomes rather difficult, and ultimately you being missing reps. Add the inevitably fluctuation in stressors from outside life events, and it's clear that maintenance is a flawed idea.

 

In reality, training typically looks like a wave, with periods of great progress followed by deloads, intentional or not. While it's possible to maintain your strength for a short period of time -- the crest of the wave, to extend the metaphor -- eventually we must either continue to adapt by getting stronger or begin to detrain.

 

Got a question for Matt and Scott? Email us at questions@barbell-logic.com and we'll answer your question on an upcoming Saturday Q&A!

 

Discounts

  1. Get 3 months of coaching at Starting Strength Online Coaching for just $500! Use SUMMERGAINZ at checkout.
  2. Use discount code LOGIC to save 10% off microplates, dumbbell microplates, and more at Microgainz
  3. Use discount code LOGIC to save $10 off belts and more at Dominion Strength

 

Discounts

  1. Get 3 months of coaching at Barbell Logic Online Coaching for just $500! Use SUMMERGAINZ at checkout.
  2. Use discount code LOGIC to save 10% off microplates, dumbbell microplates, and more at Microgainz
  3. Use discount code LOGIC to save $10 off belts and more at Dominion Strength

 

Connect With Matt